I was recently looking through a book called
Nonnative Invasive Plants of Southern Forests given to me by a friend at a local park system. The book was published in 2003 by the US Department of Agriculture, so new plants may have become invasive since then and others may have become
less invasive, but I think the book is still a good primer on what
not to plant if you live in the Southeast.
Why is planting potentially-invasive exotic plants a Bad Idea? Sometimes, exotic plants (those that have recently been imported to an ecosystem within the last century or two) lack any natural "predators" (i.e. diseases or insects) to keep them under control. If the exotics are particularly fertile, they can overwhelm local ecosystems, wreck biodiversity and often cause havoc for local fauna that may not be able to gain any value from the invaders. In other words, a plant that resists deer and rabbits may be perfect for your yard, but if it becomes widespread in the woods and animals can't eat it, then they could starve. At least, that's my understanding of the problem.
I'm not going to make any blanket statements here saying you should never, ever,
ever plant any of these plants. (Although Taylor Swift
would probably say something like that.) We all have to use our own judgment. But I prefer to err on the side of caution. Nature is already being assaulted from so many angles by humans, I'd rather not contribute to the problem.
So if you see any of these being sold in local nurseries, perhaps talk with the owner about whether he/she might be willing to stop carrying these plants. And perhaps you can consider volunteering to remove exotics from our local forests.
Note - Invasiveness typically varies dramatically according to climate and other factors. These plants are (or were in 2003) considered invasive in the Southeast - the Carolinas, Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, Mississippi, Louisiana, Alabama, Arkansas, Texas, Oklahoma and Kentucky. Outside of this region -- and even for certain states within this region -- some of these plants
may not be invasive. But then again, there are other
plants that are dreadfully invasive in California or the Southwestern deserts or the Northern plains or the Northeastern forests. So check with your local plant authorities if you live in one of those zones to get your own list of invasive plants to shun.
Without further adieu, here are the blacklisted invasives from the 2003 USDA publication:
Invasive Trees
-
Ailanthus altissima, Tree-of-Heaven, Stinking Sumac.
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Ailanthus altissima:
"This tree is one of the most invasive weeds I have ever experienced. It
literally once grew from a crack in the foundation of my house. One of
them was growing into a chain link fence at the back of my home when I
moved in, and I cut it down every year for 15 years and it even survived
being burned with gasoline...I absolutely hate these with a passion, and they grow
everywhere here."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Albizia julibrissin:
"First lightning hit it so it grew double trunks. Then ants ate it,
causing one half to fall on my house. I had it removed and stump grinded
and I am still pulling on little trees every summer and probably will
still be at age 80 or when hell freezes over."
Favorite Dave's garden quote about
Paulownia tomentosa:
"Run, run, run away from this tree!
I had two ancient Paulownia tomentosas removed from the front yard of our new house in May of 2007.
I had the roots ground out as deep as the largest grinder would go. The
roots shoots that came up that year were horrendous- one every foot
covering the entire yard. It was literally a daily chore to keep up with
them- you'd cut them all then the next morning there would be another
hundred of them 2 inches tall.
They came up again equally as bad in 2008, all spring and summer.
In 2009 they slowed down a bit on my property but began seeking new areas
as I saw them in neighbor yards as well- not only on the adjoining
properties but across the street as well.
Spring and summer of 2010- three full years since I had the trees taken out- and I still got shoots.
THREE YEARS!
They slowed down considerably but I still had to cut down one or two every couple of days. They are impossible to pull. They are one tenacious tree.
AND...I cut more root shoots this spring!!! Four. Full. Years. After the trees were removed. This tree is the devil!!!"
Favorite
Dave's Garden quote about Melia azedarach:
"There's nothing worse than a cluster of fruit smacking you in the head or
your bare feet landing upon a mushy cluster. Doesnt get along well with
high winds and throws branches throughout the year, including older
branches which tend to prefer softening their landing upon the neighbors
house. The messiest tree I've ever seen. Also one of the ugliest trees
when all of the leaves have fallen."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Triadica sebifera:
"I have many names for this "trash" tree, none of which I can say here.
The only good thing about it is the nice fall color it gets. You cannot
drive anywhere in my town without seeing forests of these in every
field. The field behind our house had tons of them, and when they
started to develop the area, the trees were cut down. Unfortunately,
this caused millions of offshoots to creep up in our backyard...even 15 years later we are still having to cut the little trees down.
AAAAAHHHH"
-
Elaeagnus angustifolia, Russian Olive, Oleaster
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about Elaeagnus angustifolia:
"This tree is absolutely horrible. My neighbors have some, and every year
we have to go out and kill the sprouts that have appeared on our yard.
We let them get big once, and it was a definite battle to get past the
thorns and cut it down."
Invasive Shrubs
-
Elaeagnus pungens, Silverthorn, Thorny Olive
-
Elaeagnus umbellata, Autumn Olive
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Euonymus alatus:
"My wife planted some next to her house before we met. Now we end up
pulling young ones on our daily walks around the property. They sprout
up throughout our woods where you might think the leaf cover would
prevent introduction. Planting this species is a great disservice to
everyone around you. Intentional or not, you are deciding that they
will have it too. Would you thank your neighbor for planting kudzu?"
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Ligustrum sinense:
"This plant is a disaster. It has almost taken over the woods behind my
house. I cant cut it down fast enough. Foliar herbicides sprays do not
work. The cut stump treatment is the only way to get rid of it. Small
seedlings can be pulled up by hand after the ground is wet."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Ligustrum japonicum:
"Like Ligustrum sinensis, this is an exotic invasive species. Wildlife
disperse the seeds from its abundant drupes, which then sprout and grow
with amazing vigor in Southern woodlands. They compete with native
understory plants and even suppress native hardwood regeneration. Like
kudzu, it is extremely difficult to remove once it has established
itself. We would be better off if Ligustrum had never been imported to N
America."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Lonicera maackii:
"The small to medium sized shrubs of my uniformed youth have become the
shrubs of regret in my adulthood. The if-only-I-knew-thens roll off my
tongue like the numerous knarled and crouching branches that, along with
the various confusing forms of buckthorn, dominate the backyard border
understory at my family homestead in Southwestern Ohio's Mad River
Valley. They seem to bend spider-like. Woody sentries guarding the
unwanted groundcovers of garlic mustard and nettles."
-
Lonicera morrowii, Morrow's Honeysuckle
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Lonicera morrowii:
"Native to Japan, Korea, and Northeast China, Morrow's Honeysuckle is
highly invasive in the Northeast and Midwest of the United States. I am
battling it like crazy in our woods in Indiana. Morrow's Honeysuckle
thrives at the edges of forests, roads, or other natural or man-made
barriers, but is not limited to them, and is found in both mature and
disturbed forests. In some areas, Morrow's Honeysuckle is the dominant
plant species, especially in areas of disturbed ecological succession.
It is suspected that Lonicera morrowii is allelopathic, and may
capitalize on disturbed ecological succession by establishing itself and
then preventing the growth of plants underneath it. With a sufficiently
established thicket of honeysuckle, even other shade-tolerant, invasive
species, such as Fortune's Spindle have difficulty growing underneath
it, whether due to its suspected allelopathic activity or through soil
depletion. Due to its early leafing, Morrow's Honeysuckle is
particularly harmful to spring ephemerals, flowers that evolved to bloom
briefly in the spring before other plants leafed out.
If you live in North America, please choose a native bush like Bottlebrush Buckeye, Ninebark or Black Chokecherry instead."
May not be as invasive as some of the other Bush Honeysuckles, at least in certain climates, but
Paghat's Garden does note that "it is regarded as an invasive pest in Tennessee."
-
Lonicera xbella, Bell's Honeysuckle
I would never plant this, but if you absolutely must have it, at least make sure you buy from a respectable nursery to get a hybrid that will not produce viable seeds.
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Nandina domestica:
"PURE EVIL!!!!! Super invasive!!!
The previous owners of my house planted this along the fence toward one
side of my backyard, then they abandoned the house for 5 years. By the
time I bought the house it had spread ALL OVER. It had made its way to
the other side of the backyard, and into my neighbors yards. It actually
started moving my heat pump and broke up a brick and mortar garden (all
of this was on the far side opposite where it was originally planted)
It is a nightmare to get rid of!! I have probably spent more the 50
hours pulling it all out. The thick, deep root nests were worse then
what I had seen with bamboo. An axe would bounce right off them barely
doing any damage.
I still have bits of it popping up, and even worse some of it must have
gotten loose while I was pulling it out and now it's been popping up in
my front yard. No weed/brush/vine killer has effected it. I had even
tried root rot which did nothing.
A lot of sites and garden centers don't say anything to indicate how
invasive this plant is. They really need to give people a warning."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Rosa multiflora:
"This plant was introduced to PA by the PA dept of agriculture, who, in
their infinite "wisdom" thought it would be a great way of controlling
erosion on stream banks.
This plant, however, is spread rapidly by birds, and when it moves into
an area, it will choke out native shrubs, perennials and any other
plants it can push out. I've even seen a large clump of these climbing
roses kill a TREE!! The only plants I've seen that can successfully
compete with this menace (without killing natives) are bamboo (which,
due to it rapid and tall shoot growth can actually penetrate a mass of
this bush and ultimately shade it out), and our native trumpet vines
(which are just about as good at climbing, rapid growth and spreading by
suckers as this foreign invader is).
The only effective biological control (other than the aformentioned
plants) is some type of blight (that originated, ironically enough, from
our native roses) that causes deformed growth on the plant (ala witch's
broom), followed by general wiltage and eventually death.
I found one good way to take out a multiflora rose thicket, and send it
down for the count, is to first use either long-handled pruning shears
or a machete (or, in my case I use my longsword) to whack off the outer
branches (which can then be either chipped or tossed onto the ol' brush
pile), then use a good garden shovel to dig up as much of the roots as
you can. I've used this elimination method for well over a dozen
multiflora roses on my property, and never had one come back.
This plant is considered a noxious weed in PA, so I terminate it with extreme prejudice."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Rosa bracteata:
"The vicious thorns are strong. This rose can be very invasive and is
difficult to get rid of. Like other members of the rose family, such as
dewberries, and blackberries, this rose will resprout from root sections
left in the ground."
Invasive Vines
You can
read up on the differences with American Bittersweet - C. scandens - to make sure you don't pull a native vine by mistake.
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Celastrus orbiculatus:
"Very invasive! In my yard it would creep underground and pop up
anywhere, even as much as 40 yards away from any previously known
location, to climb onto and start strangling other plants. After 3 years
in the house, I don't think there were any flowerbeds or shrubs that it
DIDN'T ultimately attack. When you pull it out by the roots, bits of it
break off so it will regenerate later (only solution is to repeat every
time you see a new one). Also, if you just lay the roots on the grass
to "bake" they'll send new shoots into the ground and regrow, so after
weeding you have to lay it onto asphault or something until it shrivels.
On an interesting note, apparently slugs thrived on its bright-orange
roots, since all the slugs in my garden were orange, and their color
reverted after my ongoing anti-bittersweet campaign."
-
Dioscorea bulbifera, Air Yam
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Dioscorea bulbifera:
"This "weed" is the most horrible thing I've dealt with and it reminds me
of Kudzu (from the I-95 corridor). It has taken over the small wet land
behind our house and has completely destroyed the Florida pine trees
that are ten or twelve stories tall.
We had our first "air potato" roundup today and we gathered almost 500
lbs of potatoes. The largest sizes were larger than a softball and as
small as a corn kernel.
Any person who thinks the Air Potato is a nice, pleasant, non-invasive
plant should stop eating the potatoes because they are poisonous and
obviously impaired your judgment." (Eat the Weeds more-or-less backs up the notion that D. bulbifera is a dangerous plant to try to consume.)
-
Dioscorea oppositifolia, Chinese Yam, Cinnamon Vine Note that
Eat the Weeds author Green Deane feels that the plant growing wild in the States is actually D. polystachya. He claims that the roots and bulbils are both edible if properly cooked. Given the fact that there are many kinds of Dioscorea, some of which seem to be more poisonous than others, I would advise caution before attempting to consume any wild yams. But if you are the type of person who likes foraging for wild food,
Deane's Eat the Weeds blog seems like a good resource. I say "seems" because I can't prove that any of his claims are accurate, but he certainly seems confident in his judgment and the blog makes for very entertaining reading regardless.
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Dioscorea oppositifolia:
"This plant is terribly invasive. Each litle "potato" grows. It covers
and smothers everything. It is impossible to get rid of. It is a
nightmare when it gets loose! I have it places I cannot figure out how I
got it there. If you plant it watch it and don't put the potatoes where
you don't want them!"
-
Dioscorea alata, Water Yam
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Dioscorea alata:
"Very invasive in central Florida. I have dug hundreds of pounds of
tubers out from an area that was full of it where I was expanding my
garden. The tubers still would sprout after six months of being held on
wooden racks above ground level. They couldn't be put in compost as
they would have taken that over as well. Finally, it seems I have it
under control after three years of working at it. In my area, it can
grow over 50 feet in a season, maybe more. I don't recommend it for
anywhere south of latitude 29 degrees."
Variegated cultivars such as "
Emerald and Gold" may not have the same invasive tendencies.
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Euonymus fortunei:
"Do NOT plant this invasive vine. My neighborhood in eastern Cincinnati
is OVERRUN with it. When I bought this house, the yard (mostly shade)
was completely taken over by wintercreeper, which marches over and
through fences and scaled up shrubs and tall trees. Thick (3"-4"
diameter) ropes of it girdled tree trunks. It was a nightmare to
eradicate - took me two summers of backbreaking labor. Because my
neighbors are careless and/or lazy, they allow this invader to take over
everything in their yards, and the berries fall into my yard, which
means I have to be ever-vigilant to pull up any seedlings. Woods and
forests are being choked to death with it. Local nurseries actually sell
the stuff. I think it should be banned from sale. It's the kudzu of the
southern Midwest."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Hedera helix:
"I love the look of this ivy, but it's a nightmare. Our whole front yard
is on a slope and covered in very dense, thick bed of ivy. It is wound
all around our trees, and is slowly killing them. A large bush that used
to flower doesn't anymore -- it's being killed by the ivy. We trim it,
we've tried to eliminate the ivy off the trees to save them but it just
comes back. The worst part, though, is that we learned that we had RATS
living under our ivy. Every time we do a major trim, what happened?
Suddenly the rats freak, scurry out of the ivy and INTO OUR HOUSE.
We've had three separate rat professionals confirm this. Now we're also
finding that it's creeping under the exterior boards of our house."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Lonicera japonica:
"This is a horrible invasive smothering vine. It's taking over and
killing forest understories in many places in Eastern Kansas and Western
Missouri. It will grow over and kill just about anything in it's way.
I'd never tolerate, much less plant, it in my yard."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Pueraria montana: "This plant is not only impossible to kill, but destructive. I'm not
talking about trees or other plants (although I've seen it of course)
but it BROKE my fence. Yes, you heard right, it broke my fence, and is
working on my neighbor's. (He hates the kudzu, but I think he's given up
fighting it. I don't blame him.) I will never, EVER recommend ANYONE
plant this for ANY reason, and that includes erosion control. It's not
worth it. Let the land erode. Just don't plant kudzu.
I've sown almost one metric ton of salt into my lawn on the kudzu
areas, and that didn't kill it. My backyard caught on fire (long story,
stupid neighborhood kids) and all the kudzu was 'destroyed'. It was a
huge fire; had about 3 fire trucks parked in my front yard to put it
out. (I have a large property). Well guess what? It's back, and 'better'
than ever. Unless I can get my hands on some Agent Orange, all I can
do is hack at it with my machete and hope for the best.
I hate this plant with the burning intensity of a thousand suns,
although the heat emanating from that many suns would hardly kill it."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Vinca minor:
"The flowers are apparently not attractive to insect pollinators and
subsequently receive very few visits, if any. Foliage is toxic to
herbivores and if the occasional seed is produced it is too small to be
of interest to any wildlife. It does, however, provide cover (but not
food) to various small animals. Overall, Vinca has very low ecological
value.
Unfortunately it has a propensity to escape into shaded woodlands where
it may crowd out native species. People planting this species should
keep this in mind."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Vinca Major:
"I have both vinca major and minor in my yard. Vinca major is the much
more invasive of the two, growing over it's smaller sibling anywhere the
two meet. Let me put it this way: you know a plant is invasive when it
chokes out the baby bamboo that's randomly growing in your flower bed...
I've pulled out a pile that overflowed a wheelbarrow, but unfortunately
that was just one 10 x 2 ft area."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Wisteria sinensis:
"If you are considering acquiring this plant, first check to see if it is
invasive in your part of the country. There is much information about
invasive species on the internet or from your native plant society. Much
expense is incurred in attempts to remove it from roadsides, parks and
other natural areas. It kills trees and all native undergrowth thus
affecting the entire ecosystem. You may feel you can control it in your
yard, but you don't see what happens in all the natural areas where the
birds deposit its seeds.
There are native wisterias, frutescens and macrostachya, that are not
invasive or such strong growers that they can kill large trees and are
very attractive."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Wisteria floribunda:
"I do not recall exactly when my mother planted this monster in their back
yard, it has been many years back. This vine is now very "jungle"
like. The base going around certain trees is several inches (3 or 4) in
diameter and the "thing" just keeps on invading. I have seen it put
out long (12' to 15') shoots along the ground in a spring and early
summer. Please be careful when you select the vine for planting. It is
beautiful in full bloom but may require a lot of space for spreading."
Invasive Grasses
-
Arundo dorax, Giant Reed
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Arundo dorax:
"It is a perennial grass that can grow to over 20 feet tall. Giant reed
propers in well drained soils where abundant moisture is available such
as streams, ditches and riverbanks and grows in many soil types from
heavy clays to loose sands. It has fleshy, creeping rootstocks which
form compact masses. Its tough, fibrous roots penetrate deeply into the
soil. Giant reed root and stem fragments can float for miles and may
take root and initiate new infestations. It has a rapid growth rate
which makes it possible for it to quickly invade new areas forming pure
stands.
Giant reed can outcompete and completely suppress native vegetation once
established and it is very difficult to remove. It can choke riversides
and stream channels, interfere with flood control, increase fire
potential and reduce habitat for wildlife. In addition, the root mats
form natural dams causing debris to collect behind culverts, bridges and
other structures which lead to structural damage. Giant reed can
increase the potential for fires because it ignites easily."
Many lawns in Tennessee, including my own, are
fescue-based, although I'm not sure if they use this invasive tall fescue specifically.
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Imperata cylindrica:
"This plant is very dangerous to our ecosystem! It's taking over the
south & now banned in South Carolina. It chokes out native
vegetation & burns very easily & very hotly."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Microstegium vimineum:
"Horribly invasive grass. Spreads both by above-ground rhizome and seed...Loves disturbed soil. Able to displace native wetland and forest
understory vegetation with its dense, expanding monospecific patches.
Once established, the removal of M. vimineum requires major eradication
and restoration efforts. Likes low-light levels unlike many other
grasses (5-50%)."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Miscanthus sinensis:
"This plant is highly invasive. I have seen it take over hay fields,
roadsides and just about everywhere else. In my opinion it should be
avoided at least in Zones 6 and 7, where it appears to be most
destructive to native vegetation."
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Phyllostachys aurea:
"This was one of my first bamboo, when I didn't know any better. Since
then I have planted ove 30 species of bamboo in my old yard, but this is
only one i have regretted. This is one of the most commonly grown
bamboo in cultivation- easy to find and cheap. It is easy to grow,
too...a bit too easy. It it a runner of the number one calliber. It is
SO invasive it's scary. I planted this at one corner of the yard a
ways from everything thinking no problems (had over 1/2 acre), but it
shows up 10-15' away from its source. And then each of those take off.
Usually I just snap off new culms that show up here and there, but these
are remarkably resilient and even when bent at 90 degrees, it keeps on
growing. Hard stuff to kill!"
Invasive Fern
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Lygodium japonicum:
"This is an invasive non-native plant. It is nearly impossible, if not
completely impossible to control its spread because the means of
propagation is spores from spore sacs on elongated parts of the leaf
that are wind dispersed. The spores can also be transported to new
locations on your vehicle, clothes, or in pine straw bales. In the
forest it can form mats on the ground that can outcompete native
vegetation, thereby drastically altering habitat quality. If left
unchecked it can grow up into the tree canopy providing "ladder fuel"
when it dies back for a crown fire versus a surface fire in a wildfire
or a prescribed fire situation. As one person commented --- it's an
EVIL weed -- pretty but very destructive."
Invasive Forbs
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Alliaria petiolata:
"If I lived in an area where this plant was native, I would love it.
Unfortunately, here in the U.S. it is non-native, invasive and
destroying our forests. I've been battling this like crazy in my woods.
It's a biennial plant -rosette first year, flowers & sets seed in
second year.
Here is info from Minnesota DNR website:
"Ecological Threat:
- Garlic mustard spreads into high quality woodlands upland and floodplain forests, not just into disturbed areas.
- Invaded sites undergo a decline on native herbaceous cover within 10 years.
- Garlic mustard alters habitat suitability for native insects and thereby birds and mammals.
- This European exotic occurs now in 27 midwestern and northeastern states and in Canada. "
http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/invasives/terrestrialplants/herba...
U.S. National Park Service calls garlic mustard “a severe threat to
native plants and animals in forest communities in much of the Eastern
and Midwestern United States.”
In a nutshell, it chokes out the native plants. Trouble with that is
your wildlife, birds, insects have evolved since beginning of time to
live on the native plants, not garlic mustard. When you wipe out the
native plants, you do a good job of wiping out the native wildlife. They
say garlic mustard is creating "starvation forests" for wildlife in the
U.S.
Here's an article that addresses the issue with some humor: http://jackfsanders.tripod.com/garlicmustard.htm"
-
Lespedeza cuneata, Chinese Lespedeza
-
Solanum viarum, Tropical Soda Apple
Favorite Dave's Garden quote about
Solanum viarum:
"I wouldn't say it is a "success" in my garden, although it grows plenty
well enough even with my constant cutting, pulling, trimming, dousing
with chemicals... LOL. This is a major weed, and the only way to get
rid of it is to keep constantly on top of any new growth.... and this
may take several years. This plant "attacks" and causes an itchy skin
irritation. My father grabbed a plant by mistake and his hand was
completely covered with redness and swelling for the rest of the day and
into the next! BE CAREFUL!!"